Which tribunal hears oil taxation appeals under Schedule 5 of the Oil Taxation Act 1975?

Under Schedule 5 paragraph 10 of the Oil Taxation Act 1975, the default tribunal for oil taxation appeals is the First-tier Tribunal. This is the body that normally handles disputes between taxpayers and HMRC under the petroleum revenue tax regime. The Upper Tribunal may hear cases where Tribunal Procedure Rules so direct.

When would an oil taxation appeal be heard by the Upper Tribunal instead of the First-tier Tribunal?

An oil taxation appeal is heard by the Upper Tribunal where the Tribunal Procedure Rules direct that a particular case or type of case should go there. The Upper Tribunal typically handles more complex or significant cases, such as those raising novel points of law of general importance, as well as appeals against First-tier Tribunal decisions.

What legislative change introduced the current tribunal definition in Schedule 5 paragraph 10?

The current tribunal definition was introduced by the Transfer of Tribunal Functions and Revenue and Customs Appeals Order 2009. This order reorganised the tribunal system for tax appeals in the United Kingdom, replacing earlier references to predecessor appeal bodies such as the Special Commissioners with the First-tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal.

How does an oil company appeal a petroleum revenue tax assessment under the Oil Taxation Act 1975?

An oil company disagreeing with HMRC's petroleum revenue tax assessment may appeal to a tribunal under Schedule 5. In practice, the appeal is made to the First-tier Tribunal, which will hear the case and determine whether HMRC's assessment is correct. Only where Tribunal Procedure Rules specify otherwise will the case be heard by the Upper Tribunal.

Oil Taxation Act 1975 Schedule 5 paragraph 10

Appeals

Schedule 5 paragraph 10 defines which tribunal hears appeals relating to oil taxation matters under the Act.

The term "tribunal" used throughout Schedule 5 refers to either the First-tier Tribunal or the Upper Tribunal.
The default forum for appeals is the First-tier Tribunal.
Cases may be heard by the Upper Tribunal instead, where Tribunal Procedure Rules direct or determine this.
This definition was introduced by the 2009 transfer of tribunal functions, replacing earlier references to the former appeal bodies.

Access full legislation.And much more.

By becoming a member, your team gets full access to Tax World research tools and source-backed tax resources.

Become a member