When is a withdrawal from a Lifetime ISA exempt from the government withdrawal charge under section 7?

A withdrawal is charge-free if made after a specified age set by Treasury regulations, for a first-time residential property purchase, due to terminal illness, after the investor's death, or by transfer to another Lifetime ISA. The Treasury may also specify additional charge-free categories by regulation.

What is the clawback rule for post-age-threshold additions to a Lifetime ISA?

If an investor makes a new addition to a Lifetime ISA after reaching the qualifying age threshold and then withdraws all or part of that addition within a period specified in Treasury regulations, the government withdrawal charge can still apply. This prevents using the account as a short-term vehicle for new contributions.

Can a charge-free Lifetime ISA withdrawal become chargeable retrospectively?

Yes. Some withdrawals, particularly those for a first-time home purchase, may be initially exempt from the charge. However, if the investor subsequently fails to meet conditions set out in Treasury regulations — for example if the property purchase falls through — the withdrawal charge may be applied retrospectively.

What powers does the Treasury have to make supplementary regulations under section 7?

The Treasury has broad powers to define what qualifies as a first-time residential purchase, determine whether a withdrawal counts as being for that purpose, set criteria for terminal illness, specify conditions for charge-free transfers between Lifetime ISAs, and create additional charge-free withdrawal categories without primary legislation.

Savings (Government Contributions) Act 2017 section 7

Exemptions from the withdrawal charge on Lifetime ISAs

Section 7 sets out the circumstances in which a withdrawal from a Lifetime ISA is exempt from the government withdrawal charge described in paragraph 8.

Withdrawals are charge-free if made after a specified age, for a first-time home purchase, due to terminal illness, after death, or by transfer to another Lifetime ISA.
The Treasury may specify additional charge-free withdrawal categories by regulation, and may impose a charge on post-age-threshold additions withdrawn within a set period.
Certain withdrawals — including those for first-time home purchases — may initially be charge-free but become chargeable if subsequent conditions specified in regulations are not met.
The Treasury may make supplementary regulations defining key terms such as "first-time residential purchase", the scope of qualifying withdrawals, terminal illness criteria, and valid transfer conditions.

Access full legislation.And much more.

By becoming a member, your team gets full access to Tax World research tools and source-backed tax resources.

Become a member