What does section 259C of the Taxation (International and Other Provisions) Act 2010 cover?

Section 259C provides an overview of Chapter 3, which targets hybrid mismatches arising from financial instruments. It addresses deduction/non-inclusion mismatches where a payment generates a tax deduction for the payer but the corresponding receipt is not fully taxed for the payee, typically due to differing jurisdictional characterisations of the instrument.

How does Chapter 3 counteract hybrid mismatches from financial instruments under United Kingdom law?

The legislation follows a two-step approach. First, the mismatch is counteracted on the payer side under section 259CD by restricting or denying the payer's tax deduction. If that does not fully neutralise the mismatch, section 259CE requires the payee within UK corporation tax to bring additional amounts into taxable income.

When do the hybrid mismatch rules in Chapter 3 apply?

The rules apply when conditions in section 259CA are met, principally that either the payer or a payee is within the charge to UK corporation tax. The mismatch amount is then calculated under section 259CB, with supporting definitions in section 259CC, before counteraction measures under sections 259CD or 259CE are applied.

Can you give an example of a deduction/non-inclusion mismatch under a hybrid financial instrument?

A UK company pays £1 million interest under a hybrid instrument to a foreign company. The UK company deducts it as interest, but the foreign jurisdiction treats the receipt as an exempt dividend. This creates a £1 million mismatch. Under section 259CD, the UK company's deduction is denied to the extent of that mismatch.

Taxation (International and Other Provisions) Act 2010 section 259C

Overview of Chapter

Section 259C provides an overview of Chapter 3, which deals with counteracting hybrid or otherwise impermissible deduction/non-inclusion mismatches arising from financial instruments.

Chapter 3 targets situations where payments or quasi-payments under financial instruments give rise to a tax mismatch — typically where one party gets a tax deduction but the corresponding receipt is not fully taxed in the hands of the other party
The rules apply where either the payer or a payee is within the charge to UK corporation tax, and the mismatch is counteracted by adjusting the corporation tax treatment of that party
Where the payer is within the charge to UK corporation tax, the mismatch is counteracted on the payer side first; it is only counteracted on the payee side if the payer-side adjustment (or an equivalent adjustment under foreign law) does not fully neutralise the mismatch
Key terms such as "payment", "quasi-payment", "payment period", "relevant deduction", "payer", "payee" and "financial instrument" are defined elsewhere in the legislation (in sections 259BB and 259N respectively)

Access full legislation.And much more.

By becoming a member, your team gets full access to Tax World research tools and source-backed tax resources.

Become a member