What is the purpose of section 159 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005?

Section 159 ensures that the codification of specific deduction rules for intellectual property income and non-trading income from films, sound recordings, and telecommunication rights does not displace established general legal principles governing deductions. It prevents a negative inference that similar deduction rules cannot apply to other categories of income chargeable under the Act.

Which specific deduction rules does section 159 refer to in ITTOIA 2005?

Section 159 refers to the deduction rules in section 582 for intellectual property income taxable under section 579, and the rules in sections 612 and 617(3) to (6) for calculating income from films, sound recordings, and certain telecommunication rights under Chapters 3 and 4 of Part 5 of the Act.

Can general deduction principles still be applied to other types of income under ITTOIA 2005?

Yes. Section 159 confirms that general legal principles governing deductions, developed through case law and practice, continue to apply to all other types of chargeable income under the Act. The express codification of deduction rules for specific income categories does not restrict or narrow the deduction principles available more broadly.

What legal concern does section 159 address regarding statutory interpretation?

Section 159 addresses the interpretive principle that where Parliament expressly provides rules for one situation but not another, it may be inferred the omission was deliberate. Section 159 prevents this negative inference, ensuring that the absence of codified deduction rules for other income types does not exclude similar established principles from applying.

Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005 section 159

General deduction rules

Section 159 confirms that the codification of specific deduction rules for certain types of miscellaneous income does not displace similar established legal principles that apply when calculating other income under the Act.

The deduction rules set out for intellectual property income (such as royalties) do not override similar principles used elsewhere in the Act
The calculation rules for non-trading income from films, sound recordings, and telecommunication rights likewise do not displace equivalent rules applying to other income
Existing legal principles for calculating deductions continue to operate in relation to all other types of income and profits chargeable under the Act
The purpose is to preserve the general body of law on deductions, ensuring that codifying specific rules in one area does not create a negative inference that similar rules cannot apply elsewhere

Access full legislation.And much more.

By becoming a member, your team gets full access to Tax World research tools and source-backed tax resources.

Become a member