How are convertible employment-related securities valued under section 437 of ITEPA 2003?

Under the normal rule in section 437, convertible securities are valued as if they were not convertible. The conversion feature is stripped out for calculating income tax charges on general earnings, taxable benefits, securities acquired under options, income through third parties, and securities acquired below market value, preventing the conversion right from inflating the taxable amount at acquisition.

When does the anti-avoidance override apply to convertible securities under section 437?

The anti-avoidance override applies when the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of the arrangements under which the employee obtained the convertible securities is to avoid tax or national insurance contributions. However, the override only takes effect when it produces a higher taxable amount than the normal valuation rule ignoring convertibility.

What does 'immediately and fully convertible' mean under section 437?

It means the securities are deemed convertible right after acquisition to produce the maximum possible gain. Even if the target securities do not yet exist, they are assumed to exist. No consideration is assumed to be paid for the conversion itself and no expenses are assumed to be incurred, ensuring the highest realistic value for the conversion feature.

How does the anti-avoidance valuation work in practice for convertible securities?

Where anti-avoidance applies, conditional or deferred conversion entitlements are treated as immediate and unconditional. If circumstances must arise before conversion rights activate, those circumstances are assumed to exist immediately. If a third party must make provision for conversion, that provision is assumed made straight away, and the securities are valued at their maximum convertible worth.

Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 section 437

Adjustment of charge

Section 437 explains how to adjust the market value of convertible employment-related securities for tax purposes, and what happens when anti-avoidance rules override the normal adjustment.

When calculating tax on earnings, taxable benefits, securities acquired under options, income through third parties, or securities acquired below market value, the market value of convertible securities must be worked out as though they were not convertible.
This "ignore the conversion feature" rule does not apply where the main purpose of the arrangements is to avoid tax or national insurance contributions — unless the value ignoring convertibility would actually be higher than the anti-avoidance value.
Where the anti-avoidance rule applies, the securities are instead valued as if they were immediately and fully convertible right after acquisition, yielding the maximum possible gain, with no conversion cost or expenses assumed.
"Immediately and fully convertible" means convertible straight after acquisition to achieve the greatest gain possible at that point, assuming the target securities exist even if they do not, and assuming no consideration is given and no expenses are incurred for the conversion.

Access full legislation.And much more.

By becoming a member, your team gets full access to Tax World research tools and source-backed tax resources.

Become a member