Does a conditional discharge prevent additional liability under sections 38 to 40 of the Vehicle Excise and Registration Act 1994?

No. Section 41 provides that where a court grants an absolute or conditional discharge, or a probation order, for a section 37 offence, the person is still treated as convicted for the purposes of sections 38 to 40. This ensures additional liability for underpaid vehicle excise duty cannot be avoided through lenient sentencing outcomes.

How is the additional liability under section 38 of VERA 1994 enforced and recovered?

Any sum payable under a section 38 order is treated as a fine for enforcement and recovery purposes. In England and Wales, recovery follows Part III of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980. In Scotland, summary jurisdiction rules apply. In Northern Ireland, the Administration of Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 1954 governs recovery.

Can a court use discretion to vary the amount of additional liability under section 38?

No. While general statutory rules on fines in magistrates' courts and summary courts apply to the additional liability, any provision giving the court discretion over the amount of a fine is excluded. The additional liability amount is calculated according to the formula in section 38 and cannot be varied by the court.

What enforcement powers can courts use if a section 38 additional liability order is not paid?

Because a section 38 additional liability is treated as a fine, courts can use their full fine enforcement powers. In England and Wales, magistrates' courts may issue warrants or make deduction from earnings orders. Scotland and Northern Ireland courts have equivalent summary jurisdiction powers to recover unpaid amounts.

Vehicle Excise and Registration Act 1994 section 41

Sections 37 to 40: supplementary

Section 41 provides supplementary rules supporting the enforcement of penalties for using a vehicle without paying the correct (higher) rate of vehicle excise duty, including how court orders and additional liability amounts are treated for recovery purposes.

Where a court grants a person an absolute or conditional discharge, or a probation order, for a section 37 offence (not paying the higher rate of duty), that person is still treated as convicted for the purposes of the additional liability provisions in sections 38 to 40.
The additional liability imposed under section 38 is subject to the general statutory rules on fines in magistrates' courts and summary courts, except for any provisions that give the court discretion over the amount of a fine.
Any sum payable under a section 38 order is treated as a fine for the purposes of enforcement and recovery, regardless of whether proceedings are in England and Wales, Scotland, or Northern Ireland.
Separate recovery mechanisms apply in each jurisdiction: in England and Wales under the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, in Scotland under summary jurisdiction rules, and in Northern Ireland under the Administration of Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 1954.

Access full legislation.And much more.

By becoming a member, your team gets full access to Tax World research tools and source-backed tax resources.

Become a member